Which preposition should follow "guide" here — "on", "to", "for"?
The following link includes a guide _____ how to use it.
How should I fill in the blank? on, for, about?
Answer
Generally speaking, I personally prefer "guide to" over "guide on"; "guide about" sounds rather strange to me (though not ungrammatical).
By the way, mohang's Google results are very different from what I'm seeing:
(If I add an article in front of "guide" to make sure that I only get results where it is a noun, the picture is the same: 119,000,000 vs 4,730,000 vs 252,000 for "a", and 15,500,000 vs 2,380,000 vs 156,000 for "the".)
I checked the British National Corpus (BNC) and the Corpus of Contemporary American English (COCA), and they both seem to agree:
BNC COCA
guide.[n] to 1419 4553
guide.[n] on 37 194
guide.[n] about 4 15
guide to how 41 27
guide on how 6 16
guide about how 1 1
That being said, as Rocquie points out, two "to"s in rapid succession are not everybody's thing. I actually agree, so in this particular case, I would probably go with "on" (as Bruno suggests) or with "to" + gerund:
- a guide on how to use it
- a guide to using it
The BNC stats look as follows:
guide on how to 6
guide to how to 4
guide about how to 0
guide to using/getting/making 3/4/7
guide on using/getting/making 0/0/0
guide about using/getting/making 0/0/0
Now, what about "guide for"? That one is trickier, because it usually means something else entirely — more often than not, the for denotes the target audience rather than the subject of the guide (though the latter is not unheard of, either). Here are just a few examples from BNC and COCA:
- The Guide for the Perplexed
- A Guide for Married Couples
- a Resource Guide for the Responsible Non-Monogamist
- Evaluating the School: A Guide for Secondary Schools in the Metropolitan Borough of Solihull
- Licensing Digital Content: A Practical Guide for Librarians
- A Green Guide for Travelers
- How to Win an Election: An Ancient Guide for Modern Politicians
- a copy of Practical Guide for Asthmatics
You can't meaningfully substitute to, on or about in any of these examples.
Comments
Post a Comment