Is “Did you it?” a valid question?


My English teacher always asks “Did you it?” when she wants to know whether some student has done an exercise.


I think her question sounds horrible, and I believe it is wrong. In my opinion, she should say “Did you do it?” instead.


I would like to know whether “Did you it?” is in fact wrong.



Answer



A yes–no question that begins “Did you. . . ?” is invariably, or mandatorily, a do-auxiliary inversion. It cannot stand alone as an actual non-auxiliary. You have no verb afterwards, because to it is not English. You cannot say any of these:



  • Spoke you it?

  • Called you her?

  • Ran you the race?

  • Think you so?

  • Called you?

  • Gave you it?

  • Proposed him to her?

  • Have you it?

  • Did you it?


in Contemporary English. That is super-archaic. It might not even be understood.


It is very hard, but not impossible, to make sentences with only pronouns but no verbs come off as grammatical. Here is one such example:



“What about the Smiths? I gave her a letter.”


“And I, him.”



But just having a lone, inverted do-auxiliary without a verb for it to help out on is not going to work.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

verbs - "Baby is creeping" vs. "baby is crawling" in AmE

commas - Does this sentence have too many subjunctives?

time - English notation for hour, minutes and seconds

grammatical number - Use of lone apostrophe for plural?

etymology - Origin of "s--t eating grin"

etymology - Where does the phrase "doctored" originate?

word choice - Which is the correct spelling: “fairy” or “faerie”?